8 Contract Management KPIs Legal and Procurement Teams Should Track

You can’t optimise contract management without knowing what success looks like. That’s where contract key performance indicators (KPIs) come in.

These measurable performance indicators give Legal and Procurement teams the clarity they need to reduce risk, deliver value, and keep contracts on track.

In this guide, you'll find:

• The 8 essential contract KPIs that leading teams use

• A breakdown of how to measure each one

• How to automate contract lifecycle management KPI tracking

This article will help you focus on what truly matters and how contract management software can help you to those KPIs.

Download Your Free Procurement ebook and Templates

Contract Management KPIs to prioritise

What Are Contract Management KPIs for Legal & Procurement Teams?

Contract Management KPIs are measurable values that reflect how effectively your organisation manages its contract lifecycle. They help you:

• Benchmark performance across legal and procurement workflows

• Identify bottlenecks in contract creation, approval, and renewal cycles

• Prioritise improvements that reduce legal risk and enhance vendor accountability

• Report on outcomes that align with regulatory compliance and commercial goals

• Provide CFOs with performance insights that support cost optimisation and strategic consolidation planning

How Legal and Procurement Teams Can Set and Measure Contract KPIs

To identify the right KPIs for legal and procurement teams:

• Start with your desired outcomes: minimising legal risk, accelerating contract turnaround, and improving vendor performance

• Define clear links between each KPI and specific departmental goals (e.g. clause consistency for Legal, contract value optimisation for Procurement)

• Set baselines and performance targets based on past cycle times, risk exposure levels, and supplier benchmarks

• Adjust targets as your processes mature or as business priorities shift, especially during M&A, audits, or strategic sourcing cycles

• Consider KPIs that measure collaboration efficiency, such as average redlining rounds, as a signal of negotiation friction and legal team workload

KPI #1: Time to Signature

Definition: The total time it takes from contract initiation to signature.

Why it matters: Long cycle times delay value realisation and frustrate stakeholders.

How to measure:

• Track each phase: drafting, negotiation, legal review, approval
• Set SLA targets per phase
• Measure actuals vs expected SLA times
• Analyse delays by contract type or responsible party

KPI #2: Contract Administration Time

Definition: The time spent managing a contract post-signature.

Why it matters: Excessive admin means inefficiencies. Too little may lead to missed obligations.

How to measure:

• Log hours per contract
• Split between scheduled vs ad hoc tasks
• Benchmark against expected admin hours
• Assign costs to measure ROI on effort

KPI #3: Renewals Success Rate

Definition: The % of contracts renewed successfully and in line with policy.

Why it matters: Missed or mishandled renewals expose the business to cost or continuity risks.

How to measure:

• % of contracts renewed
• % renewed following the approved process
• % of non-renewed contracts that were avoidable or regrettable

KPI #4: Compliance with Obligations

Definition: Tracking whether all parties fulfil their contractual obligations.

Why it matters: Non-compliance leads to legal risk, penalties and reputational damage.

How to measure:

• Define obligations per contract
• Track fulfilment rates
• Use audit logs and contract plans
• Express as % compliance per review cycle

KPI #5: Contract Risk Score

Definition: A calculated score that reflects the risk exposure of a contract.

Why it matters: Helps prioritise which contracts need close oversight or renegotiation.

How to measure:

• Create risk checklists (e.g. regulatory, supplier, performance)
• Score likelihood and impact
• Use traffic light systems or quantitative scores
• Aggregate results for team or business view

KPI #6: Contract Milestone Completion

Definition: Whether contract milestones are met on time.

Why it matters: Missing milestones can impact revenue, delivery or supplier trust.

How to measure:

• Define all milestone dates in a central register
• Log completion status (on time, late, missed)
• Express as % milestones met per contract or period

KPI #7: Clause Consistency

Definition: How closely contracts stick to standard language and templates.

Why it matters: Improves speed, reduces risk, and lowers legal cost.

How to measure:

• Maintain a clause library
• Use AI or manual review to detect deviations
• Track % of contracts using non-standard language
• Monitor trends in common changes

KPI #8: Contract Redlining Rounds

Definition: The number of negotiation rounds a contract goes through before it is finalised.

Why it matters: More rounds of redlining mean higher legal cost, slower deal velocity, and more friction between parties. Reducing these rounds helps accelerate revenue and reduce operational drag.

How to measure:

• Track number of redline cycles per contract
• Identify common causes of prolonged negotiations
• Use AI clause comparison tools to standardise acceptable fallback language
• Monitor redlining trends by contract type, counterparty, or business unit

How to automate contract kPI tracking

Legal and procurement teams can enhance KPI visibility and reporting with the right software tools.

A modern vendor and contract management platform, such as Gatekeeper, supports:

• SLA Tracking on Workflows: Configure custom workflows with embedded SLA timers to monitor each stage of your pre-signature process. Automatically track Time to Signature and flag bottlenecks.
• Risk Module: Score contract and vendor risks with configurable criteria for likelihood and impact. Automatically generate and update Contract Risk Scores.
• Milestone Tracking: Maintain a central register of contractual milestones. Get automated reminders and real-time dashboards to monitor completion rates and trends.
• Clause Library & AI Comparison: Ensure clause consistency by comparing new agreements against a library of approved legal language using AI-powered analysis.
• AI-Powered Redlining: Streamline the negotiation process with automated clause analysis and fallback recommendations, cutting review times by 85%
• Renewals & Obligations Dashboards: View upcoming renewals and obligations by owner, category, or risk tier. Track compliance levels across your portfolio.
• Performance Reporting: Customisable dashboards and exportable reports allow you to benchmark performance, demonstrate ROI to leadership, and support strategic planning for CFOs.

Turn KPI Insights into strategic action

You can’t manage what you don’t measure. The KPIs above help transform contract data into action and surface opportunities to reduce risk, unlock value, and deliver consistently better outcomes. To find out more, book your Gatekeeper demo. 

FAQ

Q: What are the most important contract management KPIs?

A: The most important contract KPIs for legal and procurement teams include Time to Signature, Contract Administration Time, Renewal Success Rate, Contract Risk Score, Clause Consistency, Milestone Completion, and Obligations Compliance. These metrics help teams optimise performance, reduce risk exposure, and improve vendor accountability across the contract lifecycle.

Q: How can I measure time-to-signature for contracts?

A: Measure Time to Signature by tracking timestamps at each workflow stage, from drafting to approval and final execution. Compare actual durations against pre-defined SLA targets to identify delays, especially during legal review or third-party negotiations.

Q: Why is contract milestone tracking important?

A: Tracking milestones ensures vendors and internal teams meet contractual obligations on time. Missing key deadlines can result in service delivery failures, lost revenue, or compliance issues. Monitoring milestone completion rates helps Procurement and Legal teams drive accountability and plan for escalations.

Q: What tools can help track KPIs efficiently?

A: Contract management software with automation, AI-powered redlining, and custom dashboards - such as Gatekeeper - enable you to measure and report on contract KPIs in real time. These tools help surface insights, reduce manual effort, and support data-driven decision-making for Legal, Procurement, and Finance leaders.

Q: How do contract KPIs support CFO decision-making?

A: Contract KPIs give CFOs visibility into contractual performance, risk exposure, and vendor value realisation. Metrics like cycle time, redlining frequency, and compliance trends help Finance leaders evaluate operational efficiency and forecast obligations. This data supports more informed budgeting, vendor negotiations, and audit readiness.